What the panel prints before you open
Walk up to the booth signed TREASURE BROKER and interact with Goldtooth Gus. The panel that opens is a list of what you are carrying, and every row already tells you what the chest is worth: the chest name, a rarity chip, the sea it came from, a Gear odds multiplier, an approximate gold figure and an OPEN button.
Four chests filled a 4/4 hold in the 6 November 2026 session on record, and the panel printed “YOUR TREASURE 4/4 cargo” above them with a LUCK x1.02 chip and an ODDS button on the same line. Along the bottom sat EXPECTED GOLD ≈$1,099, a FAST button and OPEN ALL (4). So the decision is not blind: the game shows its own estimate before you commit anything.
The four row figures added up to that total exactly — 450 + 375 + 155 + 119 = 1,099 — which is the one cross-check this panel offers. Opening one chest at a time showed the same thing: a lone Merchant Chest printed ≈$266 on its row and “EXPECTED GOLD ≈$266” underneath.
What each chest type showed
Six chest types turned up across three visits in the same session. Read these as one session's readings, not as a price list: the figure is an estimate the panel prints, and the panel does not say what produces each type.
| Chest | Rarity on the row | Gear odds | Expected gold | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Captain's Chest | Rare | x2.5 | $450 | Opened in the same session, and the row carried the “IN YOUR HANDS” chip |
| Pirate Chest | Rare | x2.5 | $375 | No extra chip on the row |
| Pearl Clam | Uncommon | x1.5 | $155 | No extra chip on the row |
| Wooden Chest | Common | x1 | $119 | The cheapest row in the panel |
| Merchant Chest | Uncommon | x1.6 | $266 | Read alone at 6:54, expected gold $266 |
| Silver Coffer | Uncommon | x1.3 | $170 | Read alone at 6:40, expected gold $170 |
Every row also carried a CALM chip, which is the sea the chest came from, so a chest from another sea would print a different tag. The rarity and the gear odds do not run together: the two Rare chests both read x2.5, but the three Uncommon rows read x1.3, x1.5 and x1.6. The multiplier tracks the chest, not the rarity chip.
What the multiplier does is not printed anywhere on the panel. A x2.5 row and a x1 row can sit side by side with the same kind of gold estimate, so the odds column is a reason to prefer one chest over another only once you know what it changes — and that is the ODDS button, which the recording never shows opened.
What came back out of four chests
Opening all four produced a second panel, headed YOUR HAUL, with one line at the top: “4 treasures opened · +$1,202”. That is $103 more than the $1,099 the panel estimated, so treat the estimate as an estimate.
Below the number sat four gear cards, each stamped with odds of its own: a Rusty Machete at 1 in 3, two Patched Vests at 1 in 12 each, and a Rope Coil at 1 in 40. Three of the four cards carried a red corner dot and the fourth, a Rope Coil, a green one. Only the duplicate vest was greyed out and stamped SCRAPPED.
Two buttons close the panel: SCRAP COMMONS +$20 and DONE, the second bound to the space bar. So a haul is not only coins — it is coins plus gear you keep or scrap, and the game values the commons it is willing to take back at $20 for the stack.
These are the only odds this page can quote: the per-chest Gear odds multiplier on the first panel, and the per-item 1 in N on the haul card. Nothing on either panel links the two.
Luck, and the setting that skips the animation
The LUCK chip sits beside the ODDS button and read x1.02 on two of the three visits and x1.07 on the third, at 6:03 and 6:54 of the recording. Nothing on screen explains the change: the same hold, the same session and the same player. Read a LUCK multiplier as a live number you check, not a fixed stat you memorise.
If the opening animation is what you want to skip, the switch is in the main menu: Settings, then the GAMEPLAY block, then Fast Chest Opening — “Skip to the haul at the Broker”. In this recording it sat switched off between Show Tips and Crew Barks, and the switch itself is the only place the game names the behaviour.
The panel also carries a FAST button next to OPEN ALL, and this recording never pressed it, so this page does not claim what it does.
I Went From NOOB to PRO in Be a Pirate! ROBLOX
Video by CHALLS
The broker panel with four chests, the $1,099 expected total, and the haul panel that paid $1,202 with four gear cards. Watch on YouTube
What this page could not read
Five things would each change how you use the counter, and none of them was readable in the material:
- The ODDS table. The button is on the panel and the recording never shows it opened, so the odds behind each chest type are unread.
- What moves LUCK. Two different values printed in one session with nothing on screen to explain either.
- Where each chest comes from. No frame shows a dig, a drop or a shop that produces a Captain's Chest, Pearl Clam, Merchant Chest or Silver Coffer. The sea chip only says which sea it was in.
- Whether OPEN ALL rolls each chest separately. Four chests produced four results, but the roll logic is not printed.
- What the FAST button does. Never pressed.
If the question is which chest to go and dig rather than what to do at the counter, the answer lives in the treasure map guide and the island list. If the hold is already full before you reach port, the cargo guide covers that.